The Sweet Menu
Classic Flavors
Vanilla
Chocolate
Marble
Almond
Red Velvet
Confetti
Strawberry
Lemon
Specialty Flavors
Carrot
Pink Champagne
Raspberry Almond Swirl
Cookie Butter
Pumpkin
Spiced Apple
Lemon Blueberry
Buttercream Flavors
Vanilla
Chocolate
Almond
Coffee
Lemon
Strawberry
Filling Options
Chocolate Fudge
Salted Caramel
Cookie Butter
Fruit Jams
Lemon Curd
Cookies n' Cream
Don't see the flavor you're looking for? Just ask! I love creating new specialty flavors and combinations!
Layered Cakes
Tiered Cakes
4" Round Cake 2-4
2 layers: $55+
3 layers: $65+
6" Round Cake 8-10
2 layers: $75+
3 layers: $85+
8" Round Cake 14-16
2 layers: $95+
3 layers: $105+
10" Round Cake 20-25
2 layers: $115+
3 layers: $125+
¼ Sheet Cake (9×13) 20-30
1 layer: $70+
2 layers: $90+
4"/6" Round Cakes 16-18
2 layers per cake: $140+
3 layers per cake: $160+
6"/8" Round Cakes 35-40
2 layers per cake: $225+
3 layers per cake: $250+
6"/8"/10" Round Cakes 70-75
2 layers per cake: $400+
3 layers per cake: $450+
Custom shapes, designs, extra decorations, and specialty requests may affect final pricing
Cookies
Standard Size
Dozen Minimum $42+
Mini Size
Two Dozen Minimum $42+
More Sweet Treats
Muffins
Homestyle Cookies
Dozen Minimum $36+
Cookie Bars
Dozen Minimum $40+
Cookie Cakes
10×15 Sheet Pan Stacked $50+
2 10×15 Sheet Pans Stacked 90+
Number, letter or design cutouts available
Cupcakes
Standard Size
Dozen Minimum $42+
Mini Size
Two Dozen Minimum $42+
Allergy Friendly
Bakery
Stay Sweet Bakehouse is not an allergen-free kitchen. While some products may be made without certain ingredients, all items are prepared in a kitchen where milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, sesame, and wheat are present. Cross-contact may occur, and I cannot guarantee that any product is completely free of allergens.
If you have any food allergies or dietary restrictions, please include that information in your order request form.
Courtney T.
"Highly recommend Michaela! She was so easy to work with and delivered exactly what we were wanting. She is thoughtful about everything from her ingredients to her packaging. The cakes were delicious and we received so many compliments! Will definitely work with her again in the future!"
Keegan S.
"I made an inquiry for my daughter's first birthday. I sent in an inspiration photo of what I was wanting and she delivered! The cake was gorgeous and exactly what I had wanted. The taste was wonderful too. Easy to communicate with and pick up. Would recommend and use again!"
Bailey M.
"Michaela is so sweet & very accommodating! The cake she made for us was amazing and delicious! She paid attention to every detail and the whole process was very easy & she made sure to set expectations! Will definitely order again for future special dates :)"
Courtney M.
"I reached out just a few days before I needed a cake, and her responses were almost immediate. The entire process was so easy and stress-free. The cake itself was absolutely amazing - beautiful, fresh, and delicious. You can truly tell how much care she puts into her work. I'll definitely be ordering again and highly recommend her if you're looking for something special!"